What is privilege in urology?

Answer: it is sitting at the feet of a famous, much admired senior colleague and absorbing his or her wisdom and hanging onto every word. Some of us had such a privilege in the late 1960s when we attended the ward rounds and radiological sessions at Great Ormond Street Hospital and at the Shaftesbury Hospital, led by Sir David Innes Williams. The standard studies then were intravenous urograms and micturating cystograms, often showing gross dilatation of the urinary tracts in boys with posterior urethral valves. In the absence of vesico-ureteric reflux, the burning question was whether or not the ureter was obstructed and if so, whether any form of surgery was applicable. What a challenge!

For me it was a light-bulb moment and it set me off on a career-long challenge to define and investigate urinary obstruction and to provide adequate evidence for whether or not any form of reconstructive surgery might be helpful. Are we any clearer now than we were then? I like to think so.

Who else can remember those halcyon days I wonder?

Read Robert Whitaker’s full article here. 

Comment (1) Add yours ↓
  1. Dr John Nash retired Hospital Practitioner in Urology

    I was fascinated to read Bob Whitaker’s article on the development of Paediatric Urology and of what is “Privilege”. I agree with him that the latter is sitting at the feet of a senior colleague and hanging onto every word, absorbing his or her wisdom.

    Bob will not remember me, but I had the pleasure of working for him and Patrick Doyle for 6 months, as a Urology SHO at Addenbrookes, in 1985. Whilst he is known internationally for his work on pressure:flow in dilated ureters, his orchidopexy technique was something of pure wonder to observe and learn. His teaching on cord mobilisation, particularly on gentle dissection of the ligaments of Denis Browne at the deep inguinal ring, to avoid cord tension should be the gold standard reference for training paediatric urologists. I remember passing on this technique to colleagues in my subsequent posts.

    My best wishes to Bob ( always “Mr Whitaker” of course in those days!)

    December 19, 2017 Reply

Your Comment

All comments are moderated. Trends in Urology & Men’s Health reserves the right not to publish material we deem inappropriate.

Web design and marketing agency Leamington Spa